Skip to Main Content

Whole & Holy: The gift of not being liked

By: Melissa Hiatt, leadership consultant| November 16, 2026

Melissa Hiatt

Melissa Hiatt

My emotional health journey began after seven years of serving as an associate pastor. My people-pleasing tendencies, workaholism, and perfectionist nature left me exhausted, and I knew something needed to change. It turns out it was me; I needed to change. I left the pastorate and enrolled in a Clinical Pastoral Education (CPE) summer internship in Omaha, Nebraska. I then returned to Sioux Falls, South Dakota, to complete a chaplain residency at the Sioux Falls Veterans Administration Hospital.

I will forever be grateful for CPE; it is where my emotional healing began.  Below is an article that I wrote 10 years ago – a year and a half after completing my chaplain residency – for the From the Pulpit column of the Sioux Falls Argus Leader on Thanksgiving Day, November 25, 2016.

The gift of not being liked remains one of the greatest gifts I’ve ever been given. I still struggle when people don't like me; it’s a normal human response. The biggest difference now is that I really do like myself. I like my humor, my courage, and the way I love God and others very much. And when I act in a way that isn't aligned with who I want to be, I have to do something about it. The gift of not being liked brought me to a place that allowed me to like myself. For that, I will always be grateful.    


The Gift of Not Being Liked

The best gift I’ve ever been given was not being liked. I was doing a chaplain residency when I sensed that “Karen,” one of my supervisors, really didn’t like me, or at least wasn’t overly impressed. I was one of eight residents, and there was one other supervisor. Every quarter, each resident was required to write a 10- to 12-page paper including verbatims and reflect upon our developing theories and work as chaplains. I learned to receive and give feedback as we shared our work among that group. It was a rich learning environment.  However, it was Karen’s approval that I sought.  Karen was good, and there was a part of me that knew she could see through my “perfection,” and I wondered what she saw.

It was the last time we would all be together, and I wanted to get a “Good job!” from Karen.  I presented my year's worth of learning and received constructive feedback from everyone except Karen. Karen sat silent. We were about to move on when Karen finally spoke.

She asked, “Melissa, are you a good chaplain?”

I paused and said, “I hope so.”

She asked again, “Melissa, are you a good chaplain?”

I thought for a minute and said, “I’m trying to be.”

A third time she asked, “Melissa, are you a good chaplain?”

This time I looked down at what represented a year's worth of hard work. It wasn’t perfect, but I had done a lot of good, even great work. I looked up and said, “Yes! I’m a good chaplain.”

Karen said, “Then why are you waiting for people to tell you?”

In that moment, a shift occurred in my thinking and understanding about me and my worth. My whole life, in subtle ways, I had let people tell me if I was good or not. I had let other people determine my worth. I was dependent upon recognition and praise to feel good about myself.

Karen gave me a life-changing gift that day, and as a result, I began to trust myself. I am not perfect, but I am really good at what I do. Praise does not inflate me like it used to, and criticism refines me rather than defeats me. 

When we need others to validate our worth, we use people, we manipulate people, and, most often, we deceive ourselves. I’m not perfect, but that’s not the point. I believe in who God has created me to be, and I try to lean into the moments God entrusts to me. Now I know that I’m good at what I do – I’m a good mom, I’m a good wife, and I’m a good chaplain. I’m good at being me.

Melissa Hiatt is a former Baptist pastor who has been connected with the Dakotas and Minnesota Conference since 2021, when she began offering classes with clergy groups and individual coaching with pastors. She states, "I have loved my work with the Dakota and Minnesota Conference. I have a heart for pastors and find great joy in helping them untangle emotionally and providing tools to live and lead wholeheartedly (Jer 29:13)"

UMC

Dakotas Annual Conference of The United Methodist Church 605.996.6552 https://www.dakotasumc.org/media/library/fluid-mod-setting/12/logo/logo.png https://www.dakotasumc.org/media/library/fluid-mod-page/2/slideshow_home/Revised post-conf. 2026 -v2.jpg 1331 W University Ave. Mitchell SD 57301-0460 US 43.69689310 -98.03291320 122 W. Franklin Avenue Minneapolis MN 55404 US 44.96293526 -93.28043596 1331 W University Ave Mitchell SD 57301-0460 US 43.69689310 -98.03291320 1331 W University Ave Mitchell SD 57301-0460 US 43.69689310 -98.03291320 http://www.facebook.com/dakotasumc http://www.twitter.com/DakotasUM https://vimeo.com/dakotasumc https://www.instagram.com/dakotasumc https://www.flickr.com/photos/dakotasumc/albums